Title: O Senador / en. The Senator
Year: 2019
Director: Mauro Carvalho
Cast: Sergio Harger, Johnny Alcántara, Juliana Zancanaro
Genre: Thriller
Running time: 86 min
Country of origin: Brazil
There are films where, from the very start, I have no idea what to expect. And there are those where I’m almost certain I know what I’m watching: what the characters are like, who’s good, who’s bad and which way the story will go.
O Senador (The Senator), from 2024, belongs to the second group.
At least, that’s what I thought.
Throughout the film I felt I was following a rather familiar story. Politics, power, secret love affairs, hypocrisy, ambition and people prepared to do almost anything for their own interests.
Nothing particularly new.
At one point I even started rooting for a particular outcome, fairly sure that I understood the main characters’ motives.
And then came the ending.
It left me with a question I don’t much like asking after a film: ‘Wait, what did I actually just watch?’
Not because I didn’t understand the basic plot. More because I’m not sure whether the film was trying to surprise me, trick me or simply confirm everything I’d assumed from the start.
Perhaps it managed a bit of all three.
When a Politician Has Two Biographies
The story takes us into the world of the Brazilian senator Arthur Alencar, an influential conservative politician whose public life and private desires have very little in common.
In public, he champions traditional values and political positions that aren’t exactly friendly towards the gay community.
Away from the public eye, however, he keeps up a secret relationship with a young man, Renan.
Sound familiar?
Of course it does.
The powerful politician who publicly condemns what he privately practises has almost become a genre of its own.
And not only in film.
When a politician appears in a story speaking loudly about morality and family values, I somehow automatically expect something behind closed doors that he’d very much like to hide from his own voters.
Perhaps I’m being unfair.
Perhaps I’ve simply watched too many films.
Or perhaps we’ve grown so used to political hypocrisy that nothing surprises us any more.
O Senador builds a large part of its story on exactly that assumption.
The senator isn’t a particularly complex character. His actions, his treatment of people and the way he uses his position reveal fairly quickly what kind of man he is.
And that brings us to the first dilemma.
Is the film deliberately using a recognisable political stereotype to criticise hypocrisy and the abuse of power, or did it simply not try to give its main villain a little more character?
I’m not entirely sure.
But while watching, I felt no great need to look for excuses for him.
Love, Self-Interest and the Price Someone Pays
At the centre of the story isn’t only the senator but Renan, a young man in a relationship where it’s hard to speak of equality.
On one side there’s a rich, influential politician with money, connections and power.
On the other, a young man whose daily life is largely tied to the man who provides his material security.
Then Victor appears, a journalist trying to expose the senator’s double life, who at the same time grows emotionally close to Renan.
From that moment, things get considerably more interesting.
Because now I’m no longer just watching a politician’s secret homosexual relationship. I’m watching a young man who has to choose between what he has, what he feels and what he might lose.
And more than once I wondered how free his decisions really are.
Is being in love strong enough to outweigh material security? Is what he feels for the journalist genuine, or merely a way out of a relationship he no longer wants to be in?
Or perhaps he’s utterly naive and has no idea what kind of game he’s stepping into.
In a world where money and power set the rules, feelings can easily become the weakest link.
That’s exactly why I occasionally felt I was watching a man falling in love at the wrong time, in the wrong place and in circumstances where love matters to hardly anyone.
Except, perhaps, to him.
Stereotypes Too Familiar to Surprise Us
The film relies on several very recognisable stereotypes.
We have the conservative politician who publicly condemns homosexuality while privately having sex with a man.
We have the young, attractive lover whose closeness to an older, wealthy man is also bound up with material interest.
We have the journalist who wants to expose the truth but gets emotionally entangled in the story he’s investigating.
These are characters we’ve seen many times before.
Especially in films that try to link politics, sexuality and social hypocrisy.
Still, their predictability isn’t necessarily a problem.
Stereotypes sometimes exist precisely because we recognise certain patterns of behaviour. The problem arises when characters remain trapped in those patterns, with no chance to show anything more.
Here I occasionally felt that.
As if the film were counting on me already having formed an opinion about politicians, their secrets and relationships built on power.
And as if it were enough to show me familiar characters so that I’d fill in all the gaps myself.
Perhaps that’s why the story at times felt so predictable.
It’s all there, it’s all recognisable, and almost every character seems to confirm what I’d already thought about him.
Of course, not all politicians are the same. Nor are all relationships between older and younger men built on self-interest.
But the film doesn’t give me much reason to expect anything different in its world.
Small Dramas That Sustain a Big Tension
Although the basic story isn’t particularly original, I have to admit the film held my attention.
The plot unfolds through a series of smaller conflicts, discoveries, conversations and situations in which the relationships between the characters gradually grow more complicated.
None of these scenes needs to be especially spectacular in itself.
But together they create a sense that something serious is brewing.
The film also uses a police investigation and flashbacks, so we gradually learn how different interests and relationships led to a crime.
That was enough to keep me following the story.
Even when I felt I knew which way it was heading, I wanted to see how it would all end.
Who is really telling the truth? Who is keeping something back? Who is trying to protect themselves, and who someone else?
And, perhaps most importantly, how far are people willing to go when they feel they’re losing control?
In those moments O Senador works as a perfectly decent thriller.
It isn’t especially sophisticated, but it manages to sustain tension.
And despite the familiar plot points, I found it interesting enough to keep watching.
Political Thriller, Erotic Thriller or Something in Between?
Here we come to what I perhaps missed most.
O Senador has politics, sexual relationships, secrets, blackmail, power, jealousy, murder and an investigation.
Practically all the ingredients of a provocative thriller.
And yet, when I try to say what kind of film it is, I’m not fully satisfied with any answer.
If I take it as a political thriller, I expect more seriously worked-out political games, intrigues, behind-the-scenes deals or at least a more complex portrait of the system in which it all takes place.
Politics is very important here, but it felt more like a setting that enables the story than a fully developed part of it.
If I take it as an erotic thriller, I expect sexual attraction to be bound up even more strongly with danger, manipulation and psychological tension.
The film has erotic scenes, and sexuality is certainly an important driver of the relationships between the characters.
But I didn’t feel that the erotic and the thriller fused completely into one whole.
And if it’s primarily a social satire, then I’d have liked it to be sharper, more provocative and readier to scratch seriously beneath the surface of political hypocrisy.
As it is, I have the impression that the film belongs a little to each of those genres, but to none of them enough.
And perhaps that’s exactly what I missed while watching.
Not an extra scene, another murder or a new plot twist.
But a stronger connection between everything the film already has.
Because when you put politics, sex, money, power and love into the same story, I expect those elements to collide in a way that’s impossible to separate.
Here they’re all present, but at times they seem to function each on their own.
When I Start Rooting for Someone, but I’m Not Sure Who
One of the more interesting things that happened while I was watching was that at some point I began wishing for a particular outcome.
I had my favourites, my assumptions and a fairly clear idea of who should come out as the winner of the whole story.
Which is a little odd when I think about the characters.
Nobody here is entirely free of self-interest.
Even those whose intentions seem sincere have their own desires, fears and reasons for acting as they do.
And yet, as a viewer, I wanted someone to succeed.
Perhaps because in a story about people who use power to control others, I instinctively start rooting for whoever has less of it.
Perhaps because the idea of someone choosing love over material security always appeals to me a little.
Or because I enjoy it when someone used to setting the rules finally loses control of the game.
But then an awkward question arises.
Are the people we root for really better, or do we just want them to be?
The film made me think about exactly that several times.
Because between innocence and naivety, as between love and self-interest, the line sometimes grows rather thin.
And when power and money get mixed up in the whole story, that line can almost disappear.
An Ending That Left Me With More Questions Than Answers
I don’t want to give away the ending, because it’s one of the reasons the film is worth watching.
But I can say it didn’t leave me entirely satisfied.
During the action I felt I knew what I was watching. That I understood the characters, the motives and the direction in which it was all developing.
And then the story ends in a way that made me start questioning my own assumptions.
Was there a conspiracy all along?
Were greed and the desire for power the main drivers of events?
Did I misjudge someone’s naivety?
Or is the ending just one more confirmation that in the world of this film almost nobody is who they appear to be?
Perhaps the director wanted to surprise me.
Perhaps he wanted me to think again about everything that came before.
Or perhaps he simply tried to end a rather familiar story with an unexpected twist.
The trouble is that I’m not sure the ending gave me a much deeper understanding of the characters.
A surprise on its own isn’t enough.
A good twist, at least in my view, should make me see earlier events differently. Make me remember some scene, look or line and think: ‘Of course, it was all there!’
Here I felt more that I needed to rearrange the whole story, but I wasn’t sure everything would fall into place afterwards.
And so the ending remained both interesting and slightly unsatisfying.
Perhaps that’s deliberate.
But perhaps the film simply tried to be cleverer than its screenplay allowed.
Non-American Films and the Pleasure of Discovering Something Different
Lately I’ve noticed that I’m watching more and more gay films that aren’t American productions, and often aren’t in English either.
It wasn’t any particular decision.
It just happened that way.
Brazil, Mexico and other national cinemas have started appearing more and more often on my watch list.
And I have to admit I enjoy it.
Not because I think non-American films are automatically better. They aren’t. They have their weaknesses, limitations, underdeveloped screenplays and, now and then, problematic acting, just like films from far bigger productions.
But they often bring something different.
A different rhythm, a different attitude to sexuality, less need to explain every emotion and more willingness to show situations that aren’t necessarily tailored to a wide audience.
Sometimes they’re rawer. Sometimes clumsier. Sometimes far more open in their depiction of the male body and sexuality.
And sometimes they simply have no need to hand me a neatly packaged message at the end.
Perhaps that’s one of the reasons I’ve kept exploring such films.
Even when they don’t quite succeed, they often leave me with something to think about.
O Senador is also interesting because it was directed by Mauro Carvalho, one of the people behind Primos (Cousins), which stayed with me very fondly.
And those two films could hardly be more different.
In one I watched a relationship between two men that I almost wished I could live in.
In the other I watched relationships I probably wouldn’t enter even if someone offered me a very serious sum of money.
Though, where money is concerned, one should clearly read the contract more carefully.
My Final Verdict
O Senador is a film I found interesting enough to watch to the end without feeling I was wasting my time.
The plot holds the attention, the smaller conflicts sustain the tension, and the combination of politics, sexuality, power and crime provides enough material for a provocative story.
But I can’t shake the feeling that something far stronger could have come out of all that.
As a political thriller it remains somewhat superficial.
As an erotic thriller it doesn’t use the full potential of attraction and danger.
As social criticism it relies on characters we already know, with little attempt to show us anything new.
Still, it’s far from uninteresting.
It has atmosphere, a few tense moments and an ending that made me think about what I’d watched.
I’m just not sure that thinking was down to a particularly complex story rather than to the fact that I was left with several important uncertainties.
Perhaps the basic premise is too familiar.
Perhaps the characters are too predictable.
Or perhaps I simply expected much more from a combination of politics, gay sexuality and murder.
Because when a film has everything a good thriller should have, and I’m still left missing something at the end, perhaps the problem isn’t in what’s shown but in what’s left underdeveloped.
And that’s probably the fairest way to describe my impression.
I liked O Senador enough to recommend it to fans of gay dramas and thrillers, but not enough to call it a must-see.
Someone may see in it an excellent political satire, someone else a gripping erotic thriller, and someone else just another story about hypocrisy and people who think money can buy absolutely anything.
I saw a bit of all that.
And I was left with the feeling that I’d watched a good beginning to a potentially excellent film.
And the next time a politician starts talking about morality, family values and the traditional way of life, perhaps I’ll just wonder how many phones he has and who’s really paying his bills.
I first watched it on Dekkoo; please check current availability.
Thanks for reading!
If this text meant something to you, support GayOrbitX: an independent portal, without censorship and without annoying ads. Your contribution allows us to write more and reach new stories in the field.
Do you love differently? Patreon (mesečna podrška), PayPal, Crypto
Comments
0 komentaraLeave a comment